Katia Beauchamp loved beauty products. She just couldn't figure out which ones to buy.

Like so many women, she'd accumulated a "beauty graveyard," a collection of barely used cosmetics gathering dust under her bathroom sink.

Then she saw how her friend Hayley had a beauty editor helping her choose the right products.

That sparked an idea: Put a beauty expert best friend and samples in a box.

Together, they created Birchbox, a $10 monthly subscription that eventually shipped more thanΒ 1 million boxes every month.

In today's newsletter, I unbox Katia's story, along with:

  • 3 storytelling lessons on making your idea relatable, opening doors, and adapting your pitch.

  • Fun Fact about how Katia helped create the $42.5 billion subscription box market.

  • A video where Katia shares the business plan she never finished.

Enjoy unboxing this one…LG

β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”

Founder Story: Katia Beauchamp, Birchbox

Katia Beauchamp, founder of Birchbox

Katia Beauchamp grew up in El Paso, Texas, raised mostly by a single mother who worked as a counselor at a low-income school.

When Katia was 4, she told her grandmother, her abuelita, that she was going to be president of the United States. Her abuelita said absolutely. The whole family started planning who would sit in her cabinet and who would run her security detail.

In school, Katia pushed for straight A's, perfect attendance, and club presidencies. By sixth grade, she was signing her own report cards, because the grades mattered more to her than to anyone else at home.

Her mother never demanded any of it. When Katia brought home her first B, she took her out to a celebration dinner and told her to relax. With no pressure at home, Katia grew up unafraid to fail.

A TASTE FOR BEAUTY

In high school, Katia had a friend who knew far more about beauty. At 16, the friend already owned Chanel nail polish, and she introduced Katia to designer cosmetics.

El Paso had one tiny boutique that sold the kind of high-end makeup and skincare you usually found only in big-city department stores, brands like NARS and Kiehl's. Katia hung out there. She worked at the Gap and spent a big share of her paychecks on beauty products. She planned her entire prom outfit around Chanel's Vamp, a deep merlot nail polish.

Chanel Le Vernis Nail Colour 18 Vamp

The VAMP!

She loved beauty, but much of what she knew came from a friend who knew more.

Portrait of Katia Beauchamp

Katia had always known one thing. She was not going to stay in El Paso.

After high school, she headed to Vassar College in New York, arriving on the East Coast for the first time. She majored in economics. She was fascinated by human behavior and why people make the decisions they do. And with no family financial safety net, she needed a degree that could lead to a good-paying job.

The summer before her sophomore year, she landed a coveted job at an EstΓ©e Lauder executive training program on campus. She wanted it because so many other students did.

Once inside, she got herself onto the audiovisual team, which put her in the back of the room while executives talked about how customers chose beauty products. For the first time, she saw beauty as a serious business.

THE HARDEST WAY

After college she went to work in finance in New York, first in structured finance and then in commercial real estate. She was doing well, but she did not feel challenged. After about three years, she applied to Harvard Business School and got in.

Katia arrived at Harvard with no plan to start a company. Entrepreneurship had barely been part of her vocabulary growing up.

In her first-year entrepreneurship class, the professor taught the cases with the hard parts left in: founders running out of money, personal lives strained, years of heartbreak. Most students heard a warning. Katia leaned in. Nothing would be harder than this, she thought, and that was the appeal.

It was how she would find out what she was capable of.

Katia Beauchamp
Katia Beauchamp in a studio

THE BEAUTY GRAVEYARD

In her first days on campus, Katia became close friends with Hayley Barna, a classmate in her section who sat next to her. They wrote papers together and later shared a place to live.

Katia Beauchamp and Hayley Barna

Around Thanksgiving of their second year, with graduation six months away, Katia and Hayley decided to write a business plan together, just to learn how. Both were still interviewing for regular jobs.

They started with a question. Why was nobody going after beauty online? Their research showed that only about 2% of beauty products were sold on the internet. A massive industry, and the internet had barely touched it.

The problem was also personal. Neither of them felt smart buying beauty. The aisles were endless, and becoming an informed shopper took time neither wanted to spend. So they guessed, and usually guessed wrong.

Like most women they knew, each had what they called a beauty graveyard, a pile of things tried once and kept under the sink.

A drawer of barely used beauty products

The Beauty Graveyard

Hayley's was different. Katia spent so much time at her apartment that she noticed Hayley owned only a few beauty products, and she used every one. When Katia asked why, Hayley explained. Her best friend, Mollie Chen, was a beauty editor at CondΓ© Nast who picked products for her from the magazine's sample closet and showed her how to use them.

Katia saw it right away. Everyone needed a Mollie. They would be every woman’s beauty editor best friend.

SELLING FREE SAMPLES

Within about two days they had the whole model. Too much choice made people give up, so they would make the choice small. Each month a subscriber would get a box of four or five samples picked for her own skin, hair, and taste. Enough to actually try.

The key decision came next. In department stores, samples were free, dropped into the bag after you bought something. Katia and Hayley would charge for them. They figured a person who paid for a sample would actually use it.

If a subscriber loved something, she could buy the full size from them. The sample was the appetizer.

They tested prices from $1 to $30 a month with classmates and strangers. The results backed their $10 target.

Almost everyone else, professors included, said no one would pay for samples. Katia wanted to form a company that week. Hayley wanted a test first.

SPARE 10 MINUTES?

Instead of finishing the business plan, Katia started emailing the CEOs and presidents of every beauty brand she could name. She did not have their addresses, so she guessed.

Her message was short. She was a student at Harvard Business School, starting a company that would change the beauty industry forever, and could they spare 10 minutes to hear the idea and give her advice?

Almost all of them wrote back, over the holidays, some on December 26. By January, the two students were sitting in meeting rooms with brand executives.

The first call was with Benefit Cosmetics. Katia paced the whole time. After about 30 minutes, the Benefit executive said, β€œOkay, I’m in.” Benefit would supply 200 free samples for a test and let them put its logo on their very basic website.

The Benefit logo did the next round of selling. With Benefit on board, Kiehl’s and NARS signed on too, brands she had browsed in that tiny El Paso boutique. Like her advisors, the brands believed no one would pay for samples. They just did not want to miss it if they were wrong.

Amidst all the excitement, they had not chosen a name. Then a brand executive asked, β€œWhat is the company called?”

They wanted something that worked for women and men, sounded high end, and left room to grow beyond beauty. Trees have no gender, so they looked at trees. Birch stood out. Its bark peels away like skin exfoliating, and birch trees grow best in groups. So they came up with Birchbox. They thought of others, but kept coming back to it.

By then, Hayley was traveling in Nepal and could not be reached. So Katia negotiated for birchbox.com on her own and paid about $700. She had so little money that she felt shaky spending it. When Hayley landed, Katia told her she already owned the name. Hayley loved it.

STRANGERS ONLY

For the test, they emailed their friends and asked them not to sign up, because friends would skew the results. Instead, the friends forwarded a short description and a PayPal link to people they did not know. The price was $20 for two months.

Two hundred strangers paid.

Katia and Hayley found cardboard boxes online, about the size of an old VHS tape, that fit inside flat-rate mailers. Into each one went a makeup sample, a hair product, a skincare product, and sometimes something for the body or nails. They packed every box by hand while trying to finish their final semester, often running out of class to take calls from brands. Their website was a simple WordPress page with clip art, and it took PayPal only.

An open Birchbox with sample products

The first Birchbox

Each founder put in her own savings. For Katia, it was everything she had.

The test worked. About 25% of the testers bought a full-size product through that duct-taped website. More than 1,000 people joined a waitlist by word of mouth. The business made money from the first box, because the brands supplied the samples for free.

The customers surprised them most. Katia and Hayley had pitched an inefficient market they could fix. Women wrote back emotionally, asking where this had been all their lives and admitting they had used the same face wash since they were 13.

That spring, the plan they never really wrote was a runner-up in Harvard Business School’s business plan contest.

60 MEETINGS, ZERO CHECKS

Katia graduated with business school debt and no savings left. She was also getting married that summer, to Greg Beauchamp, a boy she had first met at age 10 in elementary school in El Paso.

She and Hayley wanted to raise about $500,000 from angel investors. They took more than 60 meetings. Investors were polite and left the door open, but nobody would write the first check.

Katia was crushed. She was also certain. β€œThere’s no way that we’re wrong,” she thought. β€œSo we’re just not saying it right.”

They changed the audience and the pitch. They went to venture capital firms, which had money they needed to invest, and raised the target to about $1 million. Most of the investors were men who would never use the product, so Katia stopped selling the fun of a new lip gloss every month and pitched the facts instead:

the size of the market, how women actually shopped, and how far beauty lagged the rest of online retail.

About three weeks before the first boxes shipped, they put up a simple web page and invited the test customers and the waitlist to pay. People did. That traction turned slow investor conversations into a competition.

TOO SMALL, THEN TOO BIG

Birchbox launched in September at $10 a month, with about 600 subscribers. A few weeks later, it closed a $1.4 million seed round led by First Round Capital and Accel.

The big brands from the test pulled back. Come back when you have 10,000 subscribers, they said. A tiny startup was not worth their effort. So Birchbox filled its boxes with smaller, independent brands, some well known and some brand new.

A few months later, Birchbox had thousands of subscribers, and Katia went back. Now the brands said Birchbox was too big. Nobody could pull a few thousand samples out of a drawer. Sampling at that size had to be planned a year or more in advance.

Katia spent her days going from meeting to meeting, trying to get enough product to fill the boxes. The supply problem brought her to tears more than once. She even fantasized about breaking into department stores and taking all the samples they were wasting.

Not every executive was rooting for them. Some resented two outsiders who seemed to think they had beauty figured out. A few treated them like silly little girls who knew nothing about an industry those executives had spent decades in.

So Katia changed her approach. Instead of telling brands how sampling should work, she started asking what they needed. She came in to learn, to help each partner look smart and successful, and to show them the new customers their samples were bringing in. Slowly, the relationships started to come.

THE BOX ON THE DESK

Birchbox had no marketing budget and no time to build one. The growth came anyway.

Subscribers had boxes delivered to offices and apartment buildings, where coworkers and neighbors watched them open a bright pink box filled with surprises. Every delivery became free advertising.

A Birchbox subscription box

The Box

Birchbox cosmetics laid out on a towel

The Goodies

Beauty vloggers on YouTube needed fresh content, and Birchbox gave them something new to film every month. They paid for subscriptions themselves and shared their unboxing videos with their audiences, before anyone called them influencers.

Mollie Chen, the beauty editor who had inspired the idea, had joined just before launch. She gave every box a voice, explaining why each product was chosen and how to use it.

Customers paid every month, and brands supplied the samples, so the business largely funded itself. Birchbox hit its five-year sales target in just seven months. About a year after launch, it had more than 45,000 paying subscribers and raised $10.5 million.

THE COPYCATS ARRIVE

Within a year, copycat boxes were everywhere. Some started paying beauty brands for samples, forcing Birchbox to start spending on samples too. And the idea spread far beyond beauty. A TechCrunch reporter said she got pitched a new Birchbox for something almost every day, including a Birchbox for cocktails.

Birchbox kept growing anyway. Less than four years after launch, it had 800,000 subscribers and raised $60 million at a reported valuation of $485 million. Within five years, it surpassed 1 million subscribers. At its peak, Birchbox had about 4 million customers, more than 800 brand partners, and operations in six countries.

Two business school students had helped pioneer a whole new way to shop. Last year, the global subscription box industry was estimated at $42.5 billion.

The ride was not always smooth. As competition multiplied and investors pulled back from online retailers, Birchbox cut staff and costs, and reported its first profit the following year. Nearly eight years after launch, its largest investor took majority control. Three years later, Birchbox was sold, and Katia stepped down as CEO to become a strategic adviser.

Today, Birchbox still delivers personalized beauty boxes, carrying on the original idea of giving every woman a beauty editor best friend..

And Katia is back at it. This summer, she launched Buff Beauty, a nail care brand that landed more than 20 products in over 600 Target stores just two months later.

β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”

Storytelling Lessons: Sell the Sample

Katia Beauchamp didn't rely on one perfect pitch. She found different ways to make people understand her idea, believe in her vision, and take action. Here are three storytelling lessons founders can use to launch and grow their businesses.

#1. Turn Your Business Into Someone They Know

Instead of pitching Birchbox as a personalized beauty subscription service, Katia described it as giving every woman a beauty editor best friend. The idea came from a real person, Mollie Chen, who helped Hayley choose products. That familiar relationship made the business instantly understandable.

Action: Replace your complicated product explanation with a familiar person or relationship. Ask yourself: Who or what does my product help customers have in their lives? Then build your pitch around that connection.

#2. Ask Small. Sell Big.

Katia cold-emailed beauty CEOs with an audacious claim. But instead of asking for a partnership, she asked for 10 minutes of advice. Nearly everyone responded. Benefit's first yes helped convince Kiehl's and NARS to follow.

Action: Open your next pitch with the change you're trying to create, then make a small request. Ask for advice, feedback, or a brief conversation. Use that first yes to build credibility with your next prospect.

#3. Tailor the Story, Not the Idea

After more than 60 investor meetings without a lead investor, Katia believed they weren't communicating the opportunity effectively. Instead of focusing on the excitement of receiving beauty products, she emphasized market size, customer behavior, and paying subscribers. The new approach helped attract venture capital.

Action: When your story isn't connecting, examine your audience before changing your idea. Investors want evidence of opportunity. Customers want a solution to their problem. Partners want to know how they'll benefit. Tell the story through the lens that matters to each audience.

β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”

Fun Fact: Unboxing the Numbers

Fun Fact: Unboxing the Numbers Birchbox infographic

Birchbox started with 200 strangers willing to pay for free samples in a tiny box. What followed was anything but small.

  • 200:Β Paying customers in the first beta test.

  • $10:Β The original monthly subscription price.

  • 100:Β Investor meetings that ended in rejection

  • 7 months:Β How quickly Birchbox reached its 5-year revenue target.

  • 1 million+:Β Beauty boxes shipped every month at the peak

  • 30%:Β Share of Birchbox's revenue coming from full-size product sales in 2014.

And here's the big one:

$42.5 BILLION:Β Estimated size of the global subscription box industry in 2025, a market Birchbox helped pioneer with its beauty boxes.

β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”

Video to Watch: The Plan She Never Wrote / Beauty & The Box

In this talk at The Next Web conference in New York, Katia tells the Birchbox story from the beginning: growing up in El Paso without entrepreneurs to look up to, the business plan she and Hayley never finished, the cold emails to beauty CEOs, and the shock of hitting a five-year plan in seven months. She also explains the competitor nobody saw coming. It was not the copycats. It was women who simply were not buying beauty at all. Worth it for any founder who has to explain a new idea to a skeptical room. Watch here:

The Next Web NYC - Katia Beauchamp, Birchbox

β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”β€”

Need help with your story? I got you.

Send an email to [email protected] and someone from my team will circle back with you.

Storytelling for Entrepreneurs Issue #110 - πŸ“¦ She Sold Free Samples for $10. And Got 1M Fans.

β€”β€”β€”

You Might Also Like

View more
caret-right